This class discussion is dedicated to the loving memory of Mr. George Belk, my Father, may he rest in peace.
From Sandra,
1.) Please explain the connection between B'nei Yisroel and Shabbat.
The Shabbat is a covenantal sign that G-d established with B'nei Yisroel. It was given to Moshe and B'nei Yisroel at Mt. Sinai as part of the TenCommandments. Shabbat is a weekly reminder to rest, to concentrate on living the Torah and to pay homage to our Creator. GOOD
2.) Where are you in this process? What is your situation? Please explain.
I have observed the Shabbat since 1995. I have yet to light the candles, but am moving in that direction. I don't handle money, I don't watch TV or listen to the radio. I am usually reading and studying the Torah portion for the week. GOOD
Shalom Sandra,
Please include your name with assignment answers and questions.
It takes me a while to associate e - mail address and names, that is why I like names included.
Please fill in a few gaps for me...
Religion: Are you Jewish or non Jewish by birth?
Children living at home: Male or female? Age?
Former spouse Jewish or non Jewish by birth?
If we at BNTI can be of assistance in your learning please let us know.
Blessings, Love and peace!
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - - -
From Michal,
ASSIGNMENT ANSWERS.
Q1... "explain connection between B'nei Yisroel and Shabbat"
Answer: Shabbat is a sign between G-d and B'nei Yisroel. It is an everlasting covenant between HaShem and B'nei Yisroel. HaShem rested on that day and has commanded us, through Torah, to do the same because it is holy to us, as B'nei Yisroel. Non-Jews are not bound by this. EXCELLENT
Q2: Where are you in this process? What is your situation? Please explain.
Answer: As a Jewish convert, it is my personal opinion that if I am going to follow the faith of my forefathers Avarham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov, then I am going to follow all the mitzvot as well, including those outlined in the Torah about observing the Shabbat. If I had no intention on following the law, I could have remained a Non-Jew. I do not believe HaShem tells us to observe Shabbat for no reason. How does it feel to know you don't have to go anywhere on Shabbat? To know you don't have to take phone calls? To know you don't have to cook, clean, do laundry? Have you ever sat in silence and listened? I have six days to do all that work, and on Shabbat, it is my time with Hashem alone. It is my time to be still, silent and listen to G-d. EXCELLENT
Michal
- - - - - -
From David,
Assignment:
1.) Please explain the connection between B'nei Yisroel and Shabbat.
a) Gematria connection: B'nei Yisroel + 8 letters = Torah. GOOD
b) Shabbat observance: One of the cornerstones of the Torah - the 7th day is a space in time where we can remove ourselves from our physical world and connect to the spiritual essence of our souls GOOD
c) The B'nei Yisroel are COMMANDED to observe the Shabbat GOOD
David, ACTUALLY WHAT YOU HAVE JUST DEFINED IS "SHOMAR SHABBAT" {ONE WHO GUARDS SHABBAT} Yes, what you have just said is accurate as far as guarding Shabbat is concerned. However there is another side to this called elevating Shabbat. On my CD entitled Steps Of Observance I explain the importance for every Jew to elevate Shabbat. By this I mean that the positive Shabbat observance a Jew does elevates the holiness of the Day. So if a Jew worked on Shabbat, G-d forbid, and began only working 1/2 of Shabbat with the intention of honoring the other half, that would be an act of elevating Shabbat. If a Jew normally turned lights on and off during Shabbat but stopped in order to honor Shabbat, that would be an act of elevating Shabbat! Now on the other hand, if a Jew did not attend shul on Shabbat but began driving to shul, normally that would NOT be elevating Shabbat!
2.) Where are you in this process? What is your situation? Please explain.
a) I am inbetween the "0" and the "1" - this is a scary realization that, according to what I read in your email, I have in fact not been observing Shabbat at all. I attend services, listen to the weekly Parsha reading, do not work, meditate and recharge my soul BUT I often switch the lights on or off, listen to the radio or watch Sports on TV. My spiritual goal is to observe Shabbat 100% ...
Shalom David! {Dovid}
This is a very good goal that will help to bring Moshiach!!
Blessings, Love and peace!
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - - -
From Eugenia's Husband Derek,
Dear Dr Akiva,
My wife asked me to send this message to you as she had to return to Brazil at short notice a few weeks ago. She is due back on Thursday [Yom Chamishi]. This has meant she has been unable to complete any class assignments. In addition, she asked me to advise you that she may struggle with these as she doesn't have a great command of English just yet (although I'll certainly help her out wherever I can).
She is very keen to continue with the course.
Best Regards,
Derek H.
Shalom Eugenia's Husband,
Thanks!
Blessings, Love and peace!
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - - -
From Bill,
Dr. Belk,
I was called out of town for two weeks, (my 82 year-old-mother had brain surgery; recovering nicely) and I've just read the class rules. I apologize for inadvertently violating your rules before I even got started. However, with your permission, I would like to catch up. I have just e-mailed the first lesson to you. If my tardiness is not acceptable I am sure you will let me know.
Sincerely,
Bill S.
Shalom Bill,
Please catch up... I understand. Also please place your mother's name on our prayer list.
Blessings, Love and peace,
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
Assignment:
1.) Please explain the connection between B'nei Yisroel and Shabbat.
Shabbat, or more precisely, the observance of Shabbat, since every living being experiences the seventh day of the week, was intended as a celebration reserved only for the Jews. I use the word "reserved" in the context that it was set aside by the Most High G-d as a day for His Chosen People to rest from their labors, reflect on their relationship to the Creator, and to pay homage to HaShem through worship, GOOD both individual and corporate. Obviously, if the seventh day found them on the road while traveling, or in the field tending their flocks and herds, worship must be individual. [JEWS ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO TEND FLOCKS ON SHABBOS OR TRAVEL] If, on the other hand, they were in town, they would gather for organized corporate worship. There is much I do not know about Shabbat and I assume the next few weeks will plug some of the gaps in my knowledge. Classmates, it is necessary to take issue with Bill at the conclusion of his assignment answers.
2.) Where are you in this process? What is your situation? Please explain.
I am aware of Shabbat, probably more so in my heart than in my head. I do not always honor Shabbat as I know I should. We attend Erev Shabbat services every week. Saturday [Yom Shabbat] often becomes a work day through expediency.
My Paternal Grandmother was Jewish so you would tell me since my mother is a Gentile [Non Jew] I am not Jewish. For 60 years of my life I was a Baptist Christian and I would have probably agreed with you. Then I realized a couple years ago that if I had lived in central Europe in the mid 1930's, I could have died for being a Jew. Why then can I not live as a Jew?
I am now a member of a Messianic Synagogue, I observe the Feast Days, I serve on the Yom HaShoah Remembrance Committee and I strive to follow a Kosher diet. No Rabbi can remove the genes of Moshe from my DNA nor can any Rabbi cause me to regrow my foreskin.
In the last two years I have encountered more outright hatred from the Jewish community than anti-Semitism from the non-Jewish community. I decided to take this course to learn more about Judaism. I trust I have explained my situation satisfactorily?
Shalom,
Bill
Shalom Bill,
I could go on for pages answering your questions BUT Shuvah 101 is not designed for that purpose. First, you have made your mind up that you are Jewish and based upon less observant teachings. Yet you are by your own admission not observant of Ha Torah. One mitzvah you should work on is Shabbat observance. Second, you are Messianic. Both are in conflict with Ha Torah. Third, the absence of your foreskin does not mean you have had a brit milah nor accepted the 613 commands of Ha Torah.
Bill, I understand where you are and understand much of how you feel. I was a Messianic for 39 years. I also understand that you want to learn about Judaism but I must ask you, Why do you want to learn from me? Christian Messianics teach that Jews who do not believe in Jesus are blind of the truth and going to Hell. What light could I possible provide you based on this doctrine? I am not suggesting that you withdraw from BNTI but that you just expand your thinking some...
Thank you for learning with me...
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - -
From Adelle P.,
Assignment:
1.) Please explain the connection between B'nei Yisroel and Shabbat.
Shabbos Observance is given only to the descendants of Yisroel / Yaakov. Essentially this means, the descendants of Yaakov / Jacob‰ who have continued to guard Shabbos as originally given by Hashem. This means the descendants who have passed down proper Shabbos observance from generation to generation. So it is possible that one may be of Jewish descent yet not be included in the Torah's meaning of B'nei Yisroel.
One may have Jewish heritage but not be considered Jewish. In other words, one's father may be Jewish but that does not make the children Jewish. One' grandmother and grandfather may be Jewish but that does not make one Jewish if one's mother is not Jewish...
First, I am unclear whether Shabbos and Shabbat are interchangeable terms for the same thing / idea, or whether Shabbos refers only to the initial candle lighting. It seems also as if Shabbat might refer to the holiday and Shabbos refer to the celebration, that is a linguistic dichotomy of spirit and praxis. (I see a definite need for a Hebrew / English dictionary -- immediately!) However, a split between the spiritual and physical seems -- to my limited background -- to be more of a platonic concept than Hebrew, so I'll proceed on the basis of the terms being interchangeable.
The above is answered in BNTI Glossary which is part of the BNTI Classmate package for tuition classmates... Shabbos is the Ashkenazi pronunciation and Shabbat is the Sephardic pronunciation... They mean the same thing...
B'nei Yisroel then is not only a matter of heritage but of hereditary practice. While one may have a Semitic racial heritage of "Jewishness", if one does not have the tradition passed down to one, faithfully and seamlessly, then one has compromised the lineage of B'nei Yisroel. "Shabbat is the most important ritual observance in Judaism. ... We are commanded to remember Shabbat; but remembering means much more than merely not forgetting to observe Shabbat. It also means to remember the significance of Shabbat, both as a commemoration of creation and as a commemoration of our freedom from slavery in Egypt."VERY GOOD
The point is to retain both group and personal identity as the B'nei Yisroel: to consistently reinforce what it is that defines the difference between "them" and "us". For the B'nei Yisroel, identity is that of G-d's chosen people. This constitutes a separation from the rest of humanity, an incredible blessing that is not available to others. Always, to whom much is given, much is required. Remembrance is not enough. It is too easy to say, in essence, "Yeah, yeah, yeah. I remember already." The Shamor (observance) is frequently inconvenient in that it takes prior planning and delays activities that one might want to accomplish. The weekend is only so long, after all. Absolute observation of the restrictions and celebrations becomes a question of personal/temporal choice versus alliegance to the preservation of the Covenant. To observe all the restrictions and celebrations of Shabbat is what provides the continuity of identity, the guarantee that nothing will be lost or eroded over the generations. If one piece of a 1500 piece puzzle is lost, yes, one can still see the picture and one might think, "No big deal. The piece is probably around somewhere. I'll find it later." At what point does the loss of pieces become irreversible? At what point is the picture so compromised as to be unrecognizable? Can one pass the puzzle on to another with simply an explantion of what it is supposed to be, or does it really make a difference if the puzzle remains intact? The concept of B'nei Yisroel as the people who have faithfully practiced the "most important ritual" in unbroken generations claims that all the pieces have to be there, that the puzzle has to be passed down intact.
Shabbat is a tithing of time and attention. The L-rd [WE USE "HASHEM"] gives one the week; one gives back Shabbat. If a covenant is a contract, a broken contract has to be renegotiated. If the Covenant is broken ... can one renegotiate with G-d? GOOD
2.) Where are you in this process? What is your situation? Please explain.
As a gentile, I am "out of the loop", so to speak.
I am a retired professor of humanities: community college introductory courses. With few variations, I taught western culture up to the Renaissance. That was 10,000 years of politics, history, art, architecture, music, philosophy, religion, psychology, sociology ... from 3 continents. I told my students that the course covered about 1/3 of the library and their chances of "learning it all" in a 6 week course were even worse than their chances of winning the lottery. What I tried to provide was a scatter-shot approach of tidbits that might be interesting enough to encourage further exploration on their own.
Judaism fell after the stone age, Mesopotamia, and Egypt, and before Greece, Rome, Islam, medieval Europe (including the development of the Greek Orthodox & Roman Catholic Churchs in all their political as well as religious guises), and equatorial West Africa. Judaism was crammed into one 3-hour session: I had to cover the ancient history of a peripatetic people, the academic approach to the texts as texts, archeological evidence of the events described in the texts (and a bit of archeological evidence disputing the texts -- I'm an academic, remember?), some few aspects of the culture (such as the position of women with regard to the Law, i.e. children, marriage, divorce, ownership of property, battering ... It's hard not to notice that Proverbs has a lot to say about the difficulties of living with a contentious wife, but nothing to say about living with a man with a violent temper, and the political/social/legal position of the Jews in medieval Europe.
I am looking for something beyond the academic appreciation of a cog in the development of my own 20th century American culture. I approach this course with respect and humble profession of gross ignorance.
Adelle P.
Shalom Adelle,
There is something that you did not mention in question number two, "Spirituality." Few know about Spirituality because of the degradation of humankind. Bereishis {Genesis} 4:26 explains that just after 235 years from Creation, humankind had so drifted from our Creator's intention which we refer to as "The Original Operating System" at BNTI that "man began to call idols by the Name of Hashem." This was the introduction to all the world's present religions. Ha Torah does not consider Judaism or Spirituality to be religions...
We cover this material in Bereishis 101... Bereishis 101 teaches non Jews Spirituality and Shuvah 101 teaches Jews Judaism. I recommend that you consider enrolling in Bereishis 101. We will begin a new class in several weeks.
Blessings, Love and peace..
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - - -
From Bill,
Your comment on Question #1: [My comment is in red] Obviously, if the seventh day found them on the road while traveling, or in the field tending their flocks and herds, worship must be individual. [JEWS ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO TEND FLOCKS ON SHABBOS OR TRAVEL]
My response: [Bill's] I understand Jews are not supposed to work on Shabbos. However, sheep being dependent on the shepherd would require even more work if confined to a sheepfold for Shabbos. They would therefore have to leave them in the field to graze. Am I to assume the Shabbos goy was employed to guard the sheep from predators and lead them back to safety at nightfall?
BILL, YOU WANT TO KNOW WHAT TORAH JUDAISM TEACHES... HA TORAH SAYS REMBER THE SHABBAT... HONOR THE SHABBAT.. THIS DOES NOT EXCLUDE JEWISH SHEPHERDS!!
Your question on Question #3 "I also understand that you want to learn about Judaism but I must ask you, Why do you want to learn from me? Both Christian and Messianics teach that Jews who do not believe in Jesus are blind and going to Hell."
I found you website while surfing the Internet. I was intrigued by the description of the course (and the offer of no tuition). I spent my life as a Christian, worshipping Jesus. Three years ago I discovered Messianic Judaism and learned His name is really Yeshua. Messianic Jews feel ill at ease thinking of themselves as Christians considering all the things that have been done to Jews down through history in the name of Christianity. They want to retain the rich heritage of Judaism and keep the Feast Days, etc. They simply believe the prophecies concerning the coming Messiah, all 312 of them, have been fulfilled by Yeshua.
I did not seek your class to learn about Yeshua HaMeshiach, but as you noted above, to learn about Judaism. As to the subject of eternal destination, if you have the time and inclination to discuss it, I would be delighted to have a dialogue with you.
Shalom,
Bill S.
Shalom Bill,
It is clear to me that you want to argue, NOT LEARN. Let's get a few facts straight.
First, the New Testament was written in Greek, NOT HEBREW! Nowhere was Jesus ever called Yeshua. In the 1800's Christian Messianics began to call Jesus Yeshua. This is a Messianic invention! Next Messianics began to attempt to translate the New Testament into Hebrew. Why? According to the Trinitarian Bible Society, "for distributing the holy scriptures to the Jews." If you could read and understand Hebrew you could examine the various translations and make comparisons as I have done. It only takes a few minutes of reading to realize most Messianics have a very poor education in Hebrew!! Yet it is these people who attempted to translate the New Testament into Hebrew.
Second, this number 312 is fictitious. It is not recognized by Torah Judaism. This is another Messianic invention. You say that you want to learn about Judaism. You are learning about Judaism. Judaism exposes Jesus for who he is. To you Jesus is the Messiah. Judaism teaches that Jesus is not the Messiah. At BNTI you may refer to Jesus ONLY by the name "Jesus" NOT "Yeshua". Now you are learning Judaism! In our Three Step Enrollment we clearly state the following:
Use of Unacceptable Terms / Words
In addition there are certain terms and concepts that are not scripturally supported by Ha Tenach. Please note the following about B'nai Noach Torah Institute:
- We do not call Jesus "Yeshua"
- We do not call Jesus a "Prophet" Jesus is a 'False Prophet' see Mt. 12:40
- We do not call Jesus "the son of G-d"
- We do not refer to Jesus as "the Christ" or "the Messiah" or Ha Moshiach"
- We do not call the New Testament "the Brit Ha Dah Shaw"
- We do not refer to the New Testament as "the scripture" or "the Scriptures"
- We do not accept the common view taught by Christianity that the Christian New Testament is built upon Ha Tenach, what Christianity refers to as "the Old Testament"
- We use the Term Christian Scriptures or Christian Bible or Christian Testament.
- We do not refer to Tenach as the "Old Testament"
We use the Term Hebrew Scriptures, Hebrew Bible or Hebrew Testament.
Now classmate, we at BNTI are not suggesting that you have to believe as we do. We are only saying that in the course of your discussion with us these terms are not acceptable and will not be accepted. BNTI is not a Christian Institute and does not support many Christian teachings or doctrines. We reserve all arguments regarding Christian doctrine to the course "Messianic Challenge."
Bill, do you understand what rabbinical law is? Christians, Baptists and Messianics teach Jews are legalistic. They teach that our rabbim burden us with laws... Messianics teach Jesus was a rabbi. The Christian Testament teaches Jesus was a Rabbi. That being the situation few Messianics realize that Matthew chapter 5 is R abbinical law directed at Jesus' Talmidim... his followers of which you claim to be a follower also.. Have you considered what Jesus burdens you with in comparison to Ha Torah?
First let's learn what Judaism teaches regarding Rabbinic Law...
In the world today only several rabbium have the recognized stature and authority to make rabbinic law that Kal Yisroel will follow. Yet few rabbinic laws are made. Devarim 18:15 instructs us to obey the laws of a Prophet... This also includes changing a Torah Law for a short time. Such a things happened in the days of the Maccabees. Mattathias, a Kohein, and other pious Jews decreed that they must fight on Shabbat to defeat the enemy. This Rabbinic Law was in place in Yisroel for several years. When the war was over the law was repealed. {1 Maccabees 2:39-41}
Bill, the point to all this is many Rabbinic Laws are good. Some are not. Yet Rabbinical Law is established by Ha Torah. Not all Rabbinic Law is followed. If Kal Yisroel does not agree to follow the Law then it is not established. According to the Christian Testament Rabbi Jesus had a large following. His following respected him. Yet I find it very interesting that the writer of Matthew fails to state that Rabbi Jesus instituted rabbinic law for his followers even though it is clear that this is exactly what he did. Bill, few pastors, Christians or even Messianics realize that Jesus' directives... instructions in the Gospels are based upon his understanding of Ha Torah. I am providing you with a brief example below. It is actually not brief. Yet in the scope of 28 chapters from Matthew it is brief. I am reviewing the Rabbinical law Jesus commanded his followers to observe. In the short span of just Matthew 5, Jesus commands his followers to observe OVER 30 of his new Rabbinical Laws. In just 48 verses Jesus requires his followers to obey all these new Rabbinical Laws. Let's learn some more about Judaism. In Matthew 5 Jesus legislates more rabbinical Law in just one chapter of the Christian Testament than the total number of Laws in any chapter of Ha Torah. In all of Ha Torah there are only 613 Commandments. In comparison, one chapter of Matthew has 31 Rabbinical Laws...
Bill, as you review the Rabbinical Laws Jesus established in Matthew chapter 5 please notice that I have added the references Christians / Messianics give in the side margins of their Christian Testaments and commentaries. These references prove that Christians / Messianics who referenced and published the Christian Testament books recognized that Jesus was speaking about the Law of Moshe. Jesus made Rabbinic Law, changed Torah Law and added RabbinicLaw.
Rabbinic Law # 1 from Jesus
"Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfill. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled." Matthew 5:17, 18
Bill, this means according to 'Jesus' law' the Jewish Scripture is NOT done away with... even though Christian Messianics teach it is... Why? Because Heaven and earth still remain...
Rabbinic Law # 2 from Jesus
"Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments[Torah Mitzvahs], and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven:" Matthew 5:19
Bill, do you understand what this means? Right here in the Christian Testament Jesus proclaims that if anyone teaches you to violate... to break Ha Torah he will be the least in the kingdom of Heaven. Bill, how do we know that Jesus was referring to Ha Torah instead of the Christian Testament when he made this rabbinic Law? The Christian Testament did NOT exist at that time. The concept "ChristianTestament"... i.e., the very term "New Testament," was not even uttered until hundreds of years later. The book of Matthew was not even written until decades later... Bill, examine every reference that Jesus made to the term "Scriptures." Every instance was to Ha Tenach!! NO EXCEPTIONS!!
Rabbinic Law # 3 from Jesus
"...whosoever shall do and teach them [the mitzvahs of Torah], the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven." Matthew 5:20
This is proof that Jesus commanded his followers to obey... follow Torah. Here Jesus states that those that "do" - Do what? That do - [observe Ha Torah commandments] and that teach others to observe Torah Commandments will be called great... Jesus' own teaching rebukes Messianic teachings and doctrines...
Rabbinic Law # 4 from Jesus
"For I [Jesus] say unto you, That except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven." Matthew 5:20
Bill, do you realize that Jesus' Rabbinic Law in this area is an extreme position that Torah Judaism does not Teach. This extreme position is only taught by Jesus. "For I say unto you...' This is not a teaching of grace but of EXTREME Works which Paul, a follower of Jesus, condemns... Here is a clear addition of Rabbinic Law by Jesus. This teaching by Jesus is by far more strict than Torah... This Rabbinical Law, that you Bill as a Messianic are required to follow, is harder than any Rabbinic Law of Ha Torah!! What Jesus imposes here makes it nearly impossible for most to enter the Kingdom of Heaven for his followers!
Rabbinic Law # 5 from Jesus
"Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not kill; [Shemos 20:13] and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment: But I [Jesus] say unto you, 'That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment:'" ... Matthew 5:22
Bill, this is another extreme position that Ha Torah does not teach or endorse. Here, Jesus issues another harsh rabbinic law... This is a doctrine but it is NOT a doctrine of "Grace." Jesus is making another addition to Torah for his followers. Jesus' addition is by far more strict than anything taught in Ha Torah Judaism.
Rabbinic Law # 6 from Jesus
"...and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council..."
Matthew 5:22
This is humorous. First, after checking with a variety of Christian / Messianic commentaries I was surprised to learn that their best know NOTHING about the word "Raca". Even more interesting, the publishers who translated the New Testament from Greek into English could not find the word "Raca". So they made one up... There are a number of opinions among Christians / Messianics about what this word means. They don't know! They're guessing...
I am not going to give them any light on what they don't know... except to say, Jesus is teaching another extreme position NOT taught by Ha Torah. Ha Torah requires that an individual first be warned, then after being warned the individual must be seen by two witnesses to bring him to the Bet Din... {Jewish Supreme Court}. Bill, this is Judaism. Judaism is much more understanding than Jesus!
Rabbinic Law # 7 from Jesus
"but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire." Matthew 5:22
Bill, this is not a Torah Commandment. This is a Law Rabbi Jesus as a radical leader placed upon his followers... The word "fool" does not even appear once in the Torah. Bill, several weeks ago I wrote about Loshon Hara which Torah Judaism discusses in 31 separate places. Rabbi Jesus just raised the level of observance from 18" in Torah Judaism to over 7 feet for his followers! Do you really believe this?
Rabbinic Law # 8 from Jesus
"Leave there thy gift before the altar, and go thy way; first be reconciled to thy brother, and then come and offer thy gift." Matthew 5:24
Bill, Torah Judaism teaches that as part of Shuvah {returning / repentance} #1,one acknowledges their error, #2, makes a plan not to repeat the error and #3,pays restitution for their error to the victim. One does not approach the Mizbayach {altar} without first following the path of repentance. Torah Teaches these elements are essential for repentance. The victimized party may not forgive you. It may be impossible to be reconciled to such an individual. That is why the Bet Din rules on these matters. The Bet Din determines what is fair based upon Ha Torah. An individual may disagree with the Bet Din... The point is that one does not come
haphazardly to the mizbayach with an offering. It is well thought out. It is planned.
Rabbi Jesus' teaching lacks consideration for the expense of the offering and shows a lack of understanding regarding Ha Torah's process for repentance.
Rabbinic Law # 9 from Jesus
"Agree with thine adversary quickly, whiles thou art in the way with him; lest at any time the adversary deliver thee to the judge, and the judge deliver thee to the officer, and thou be cast into prison." Matthew 5:25
This is sickening. Nowhere in Ha Torah do we read anywhere of the word prison except for Yaakov's son Yosief being cast wrongfully into prison. When someone does wrong, Ha Torah teaches a decent, humane way of correcting the problem. Ha Torah does not teach anything about prison. Ha Tenach does speak several dozen times about Jews being tossed into prison. Jesus' teaching has to do with dealing with non-Jews.
Rabbinic Law # 10 from Jesus
"Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not commit adultery: [Shemos 20:14] But I [Jesus] say unto you, That whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart." Matthew 5:27,28
Again this is another example of an extreme teaching by Jesus. Judaism Teaches that a man should not touch a woman other than his wife. Judaism teaches modest dressing for men, women and children. Judaism teaches that a man should not compliment another man's wife. A man should limit his conversations with women other than his mother and his wife. Yet in these very areas we often violate the intention of Torah... Here once again Jesus raises the bar for his followers!! Jesus' Law is much more difficult to observe than Ha Torah!!
Rabbinic Law # 11 from Jesus
"And if thy right eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell." Matthew 5:29
Most Christians / Messianics will tell you that this verse does not actually mean pluck out your right eye if your right eye causes you to lust. They will say that Jesus was speaking only in an allegory. Regardless, this is extreme. One does not read of such self-destructive behavior in Ha Torah. In fact Ha Torah forbids any form of self-mutilation, so to even suggest mutilation of body parts in a story or an allegory is inappropriate. It is wrong! IT IS A SIN according to Torah Judaism!!
Rabbinic Law # 12 from Jesus
"And if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell." Matthew 5:30
Ha Torah does not teach the Christian concept of hell, fire and brimstone. The term hell only occurs once in all of Ha Torah. The New Testament preaches this hell concept 23 times... Here Jesus is teaching his followers that self-mutilation, a Torah violation, is better than perishing in the Christian version of Hell. This is nowhere near a Torah concept... Torah value... Torah Teaching...
Rabbinic Law # 13 from Jesus
"It hath been said, Whosoever shall put away his wife, let him give her a writing of divorcement." [Deuteronomy 24:1,2] Matthew 5:31
Devarim {Deuteronomy} 24:1 does not talk about putting one's wife away. Ha Torah recognizes that a couple may not get along. Ha Torah acknowledges that a couple may not be right for each other... Ha Torah understands marital complications. Ha Torah wants husbands and wives to enjoy each other. Ha Torah desires for couples to enjoy Shalom Bais {peace at home}. When a relationship does not work out Ha Torah teaches that a couple should divorce and seek a new, better relationship. Hashem's desire is for Shalom Bais!
Now I find it absolutely amazing how Christians blaze right by Rabbi Jesus' teaching regarding divorce. Almost half of the married Christian world has been divorced at least once! WOW! Christians by their very actions embrace Ha Torah doctrine when it comes to divorce. So, classmates, any time a Christian / Messianic approaches, ask them if they have ever been divorced. If they say "Yes!" Then tell them to practice what they preach before preaching to you...
Next, I am just beside myself. Do you know the definition of fornication? Jesus doesn't according to Matthew! Fornication is between unmarried people. The correct term should have been adultery.
Rabbinic Law # 14 from Jesus
"That whosoever shall put away his wife, saving for the cause of fornication, causeth her to commit adultery." Matthew 5:32
Ha Torah does not teach this! Ha Torah teaches it is better to find happiness in another marriage than to fight, argue, speak evil, etc. in a marriage that should have never occurred. Yet Jesus teaches his followers that if a divorced man or woman remarries they are each living in adultery. This is extreme! It is harsh! Clearly Jesus' Rabbinic Law increased the level of harshness on this good, understanding, compassionate Torah commandment. Again, much of the Christian community does not observe Jesus' rabbinical commandment here.
Rabbinic Law # 15 from Jesus
and whosoever shall marry her that is divorced committeth adultery. Matthew 5:32
Bill, I have actually met people claiming to be Christians that require a divorced person to divorce their present mate and to remarry their former mate whom they divorced. Torah Judaism does not teach this... Would you call this adding to the Law? This is what Christians... Messianics dislikes... This is what they accuse Jewish rabbium of doing! The entire New Testament is full of rabbinic law from Jesus and from Paul...
Rabbinic Law # 16 from Jesus
"Again, ye have heard that it hath been said by them of old time, Thou shalt not forswear thyself, but shalt perform unto the Lord thine oaths: [Leviticus 19:12]. But I say unto you, Swear not at all." Matthew 5:33,34
Rabbinic Law # 17 from Jesus
"Neither by heaven; for it is G[-]d's throne." Matthew 5:34
Rabbinic Law # 18 from Jesus
"Nor by the earth; for it is his footstool." Matthew 5:35
Rabbinic Law # 19 from Jesus
"Neither by Jerusalem; for it is the city of the great King." Matt. 5:35
Rabbinic Law # 20 from Jesus
"Neither shalt thou swear by thy head, because thou canst not make one hair white or black." Matthew 5:36
Rabbinic Law # 21 from Jesus
"But let your communication be, Yea, yea; Nay, nay: for whatsoever is more than these cometh of evil." Matthew 5:37
Bill, again Jesus has expanded beyond what Ha Torah teaches. Jesus is teaching a much harsher law than Ha Torah. G-d never commanded this!
Rabbinic Law # 22 from Jesus
"Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: [Shemos 21:24]. But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also." Matthew 5:38,39
Bill, the very first issue here clearly shows that Rabbi Jesus did not understand Ha Torah halacha regarding damages. G-d in His wisdom placed limits on what damages a victim could receive. When Ha Torah states an eye for an eye it does not literally mean an eye for an eye. Ha Torah means that one should pay the value of an eye. For example: the value of an eye to a doctor is greater than for an uneducated day laborer. Both have value but the value is different. Ha Torah, as stated earlier, does not teach self-destructive behavior or any form of self-mutilation.
Here we again see Jesus changing Ha Torah even though Jesus said, "Think not that I am come to destroy / change the law, or the prophets..." The point is that in every situation we have discussed so far in which Jesus has discussed Ha Torah {The 5 Books of Moshe} he has increased the level of harshness. He has made it more difficult! He has imposed a more strict law to observe. I know of few Christians / Messianics that observe this Rabbinic Law imposed upon them by Jesus.
Rabbinic Law # 23 from Jesus
"And if any man will sue thee at the law, and take away thy coat, let him have thy cloak also." Matthew 5:40
What Christian or Messianic practices this rabbinic law?
Rabbinic Law # 24 from Jesus
"And whosoever shall compel thee to go a mile, go with him twain." Matthew 5:41
How many of the Christians / Messianics that have been divorced have said 'Here, dear, take the house and the car keys also...'? Most Christians / Messianics do not follow these rabbinic commands by Jesus in the New Testament.
Rabbinic Law # 25 from Jesus
"Give to him that asketh thee." Matthew 5:42
Rabbinic Law # 26 from Jesus
"and from him that would borrow of thee turn not thou away." Matthew 5:42
Rabbinic Law # 27 from Jesus
"Ye have heard that it hath been said, Thou shalt love thy neighbour, [Leviticus 19:18] and hate thine enemy. But I [Jesus] say unto you, Love your enemy..."Matthew 5:43, 44
Bill, Ha Torah teaches us to love our neighbor. This is the same for Jew, Spiritualist and Christian... However, Jesus was mistaken when he claimed "and hate thine enemy." This is an untrue message. Ha Torah does not teach the Jew or Spiritualist to "hate their enemy."
Rabbinic Law # 28 from Jesus
"Bless them that curse you..." Matthew 5:44
Rabbinic Law # 29 from Jesus
"Do good to them that hate you..." Matthew 5:44
Rabbinic Law # 30 from Jesus
"...and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you." Matthew 5:44
"That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust. For if ye love them which love you, what reward have ye? Do not even the publicans the same? And if ye salute your brethren only, what do ye more than others? Do not even the publicans so?" Matthew 5:45 - 47
Rabbinic Law # 31 from Jesus
"Be ye therefore perfect, even as your Father which is in heaven is perfect."Matthew 5:48
Bill, after reviewing just one chapter from the New Testament book Matthew it should be quite clear that Rabbi Jesus according to the New Testament used his power to institute rabbinical law. What you have just read in Matthew 5 is NOT some Sunday School lesson by Rabbi Jesus. It is not just a sermon. IT IS RABBINIC LAW INSTITUTED BY RABBI JESUS to his followers. Knowing this has impact.
If you pay attention here you should have learned MUCH about Torah Judaism..
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - -
From Raymond K.
1.) Please explain the connection between B&Mac226;nei Yisroel and Shabbat.
In this connect between B'nei Yisroel and Shabbat there is a base of knowing that Hashem has made a mitzvah or (covenant) with the childern of Yaakov, to which there is an everlasting sign. The Sabbath is Holy because it is tied to B'nei Yisroel, and whenever there is a reference made to B'nei Yisroel there is a separtion from people and the world. So the connection that is made is one of cessation of work but also of ceasing to place self as the authority THE CONNECTION IS THE SIGN OF SHABBAT. IF JEWS DO NOT HONOR SHABBAT THEN WHERE IS THE EVIDENCE OF THE SIGN?
2.) Where are you in this process? What is your situation? Please explain. I still have a long way to go, and I feel that as I study the Torah I can know what Ineed to work on and give that the attention that I need to. I am not Jewish by birth but would like to convert if at all possible, but I am willing to take my time as I do this. I want to be sure of what I need to do before making this step.GOOD
Shalom Raymond,
Please keep me informed about where you are going with thoughts of conversion. I think you should enroll in Bereishis 101 to learn about Spirituality...
Spiritualists observe about 80 commands of Ha Torah.
Blessings, Love and peace!
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
- - - - - -
From Zenaida S.
Shalom Dr. Akiva
First of all I'd like to thank you for your warm welcome, I eagerly hope to be able to cope with this course so interesting and so different at the same time from all I've learned before in my present religion. I can tell you that I feel very attracted to Judaism, perphaps in a romantic search of my family's Sephardic roots.
Please excuse the English faults you might find in my written exchange with you as, even though I have a good command of the English language, my mother tongue is Spanish. Could you please recommend me a special Hebrew-English Dictionary containing the lexicon (words like Kohein, challah, aliyahah, etc.) used in this and other courses related to this one, or perhaps and even better a Hebrew-Spanish one?
One of the questions arising after reading your texts is: Why do you write the word G-d without the vowel? Is this vowel pronounced when speaking? I ask you to please be patient with me as all about Judaism is new to me.
Below please find my Assignment:
1) B'nei Yisroel observe the Shabbat as it is an essential element of the agreement that Jewish people have with the Creator. GOOD
2) My elders were Sephardic Jews who fled from Spain due to the religious persecution. As far as I know, first they moved to Portugal and from there to Amsterdam, Curazao, finally reaching Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic (where I was born). In Santo Domingo Sephardic Jews spread all over the country. The small size of this community and lack of communication among them due to the remoteness of their respective locations, made impossible the celebration of their rites; soon afterwards they assimilated local customs and Catholicism, and as a result I belong to the sixth generation of Christians of this family; as you can see my process is rather insignificant.
Hoping that you receive my warm regards,
Zenaida S.
From K. O.
Greetings,
Thank you for adding me to this class. I think I should withdraw as I have not been in a position to contribute at this point.
I appreciate your time and effort and thought I should withdraw to avoid any inconvenience to yourself.
Thank you again.
Shalom K. O.,
Our position at BNTI is to teach Judaism and Spirituality. Yes, we do need finances to pay our expenses, etc. but we have a Chessed Fund for those desiring to learn. Please make an application to our Board of Advisdors. All that is necessary is to write a letter stating your situation. We discuss this in the Three Step Enrolment under Chessed Fund as follows:
Chessed Fund
At B'nai Noach Torah Institute we have a Chessed Fund which is designated to assist any classmate who is in excellent standing. If funds are available in the Chessed Fund, classmates who are impoverished may request that funds from the Chessed Fund be used to pay for their course. When we say in excellent standing we mean a classmate must take their one free course at BNTI and follow procedure.
These classmates are required to do special research projects of appreciation in gratitude for learning at BNTI through use of Chessed funds.
The Chessed Fund receives money from BNTI classmates who want to lovingly reach out to those who cannot afford our courses. BNTI matches 30% of all gifts to the Chessed Fund.
Below are the assignment questions for Step 3. Thank you for taking the time to complete them. After we receive your assignment you will receive Lesson 1, G-d willing!
Blessings and peace,
Dr. Akiva Gamliel
From Ari
The connection between B'nei Yisrael and Shabbat.
The first Shabbat is enshrined in the story of Creation, when G-d rested on the seventh day after Creation
...the heaven and the earth were finished, and all their array. And on the seventh day G-d finished the work which He had been doing, and He ceased on the seventh day from all the work which He had done. And G-d blessed the seventh day and sanctified it, because on it G-d ceased from all the work of Creation which He had done.
(Genesis 2:1-3)
GOOD - ARI, IT IS ALSO GOOD THAT YOU USE THE DASH BETWEEN THE G AND THE D OF G-D... YOU MAY USE THE TERM "BEREISHIS" {IN BEGINNING} FOR GENESIS
Following their redemption from bondage in Egypt, Moshe and the Israelites with him, received a revelation that changed the status of this people from one living by faith to a nation bound by a covenant of statutory law, the Torah, presented to the people by Moses as the word of G-d. (Wouk1987).
Among these laws was the institution of the Shabbat, and the commandment to both remember and observe, as it was to be a sign between Hashem and B'nei Yisrael. GOOD
An agreement that
If you walk in my statutes and keep my covenant .I will be your G-d and you shall be my people (Lev: 26:3-12) THIS IS GOOD BUT SHEMOS {EXODUS} 31:16-17 IS CORRECT...
Therefore, Shabbat was a seal of identity, between Hashem and the children of Yisrael. An identity which would set them apart as Holy (separate)EXCELLENT
And you shall be to me a Kingdom of priests, a Holy nation (Exodus 19:6)
YOU MAY USE THE TERM "SHEMOS" {NAMES} FOR EXODUS
Wherefore the children of Israel shall keep the Sabbath, to observe throughout their generations for a perpetual covenant. Exodus 31:16-17
The following verses show that the covenant is conditional upon observance
Jerusalem's glory depending on keeping the Sabbath. Jeremiah 17:24,25,27,
G-d rebukes Israel's continued disregard of the Sabbath. Ezekiel 20: 10-13, 17-22,
ARI WE NEVER USE VERSES OF LESSER STATURE TO CORRECT HA TORAH.. HA TORAH IS PERFECT. JEREMIAH AND EZEKIEL ARE NOT. ALSO BNTI DOES NOT PERMIT CLASSMATES TO JUST MAKE REFERENCES TO ANYTHING. ONE MUST QUOTE WHAT THEY ARE MAKING REFERENCES TO. THIS SAVES TIME FOR THE PROFESSORS.. THANK YOU!
The observance of Shabbat is essential to maintain Jewish identity and to remain faithful to the fulfilment of the covenant given to B'nei {THE PUNCTUATION BETWEEN THE "B" AND THE "n" of "B'nei" IS AN APOSTROPHE, NOT A COMMA} Yisrael on Mt. Sinai. GOOD
It is a visible sign demonstrative of distinct separateness between Jews and Gentiles. WE DO NOT USE THE TERM GENTILES WE EITHER USE THE TERMS NON-JEWS OR SPIRITUALISTS. WE TRY TO BE SENSITIVE TO THE FEELINGS OF OTHERS.. THANK YOU
The Shabbat is a time where B'nei Yisrael can reflect and fully identify with who they are and what is required of them as people, it is a time of withdrawal from the demands of the world and become immersed in relationship with Hashem. It is also a time of remembrance of G-d's blessings and his promises. GOOD
Remember that you were a slave in the land of Egypt and the L-rd your G-d freed you from there with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm; therefore the L-rd your G-d has commanded you to observe the Sabbath day. (Deuteronomy 5:12-15)
YOU MAY USE THE TERM "DEVARIM" {WORDS / THINGS} FOR DEUTERONOMY
Throughout history, the Shabbat has provided B'nei Yisrael with a focal point of continuity and survival of their faith and moreover, as a people, it has maintained separateness and facilitated coherence among the Jews during times of dispersion
It is said that more than Yisrael has kept the Shabbat, the Shabbat has kept them
My position:
I am a 45 year old male (divorced) presently working as a Nurse. I am also completing a degree at a Melbourne University of which is almost completed.
Most of my life I have been preoccupied with the search for meaning, purpose and fulfilment. Raised as a Catholic, I had long abandoned the rationale that the salvation of mankind lies in a statement of faith.
After investigating many of the very extensively marketed worldviews and studying widely, I discovered myself being consistently drawn towards the faith of Judaism.
At present, I am studying the Torah, reading many books on Jewish belief, practice, history and folklore. I possess PC software that I'm using to learn Hebrew, praying,
Learning about Kosher, and trying to observe as much as I'm currently aware.
My intention is to approach a Rabbi to undertake a formal conversion.
In regard to the observance of Shabbat, I have traditionally worked Saturdays but I'm reviewing and negotiating my contracts to exclude Saturday for the purpose of full and proper observance. I have learned some of the blessings in Hebrew (Kiddush) and eat a Shabbat meal on the Friday evening. As my knowledge improves I will continue to move forward.
Ari
Shalom Ari,
Thank you for sharing with me. Your answers to the assignment were very good. In the future please remember to include the question in red before the answer in blue. Presently I review about 21 different courses. Remembering this helps. Thank you! Also please keep quotes and references together. Thank You!
The Bereishis series, Torah series and Parsha series would all be helpful to you. Also being a registered classmate would be helpful even though it is not required for this first course. Registered classmates can use the BNTI Search Engine, BNTI Glossary, Message Board, plus much more...
I am really pleased that you did your first assignment and that it was very good!
When you have the opportunity could you give me a little more detail on the book Wouk, H. (1987) This is my G-d: Canada; Little, Brown and Company Ltd...? Thank You!
May Hashem Bless you!
Dr. Akiva Gamliel Belk
References:
Kolatch, A.J. (1981). The Jewish book of why: NY; Jonathan David Pulishers, Inc.
Wouk, H. (1987) This is my G-d: Canada; Little, Brown and Company Ltd
Shalom [Dr. Akiva]
Thanks for the prompt return of my work, your encouragemnt and corrections.
The book, This is my G-d by Herman Wouk was part of a preconversion reading list obtained from a local site (Melbourne, Australia) which runs conversoin programs for non-Jews. I have found the book very readable and informative. It was described in the reading list as "a very accessible introduction to Jewish beliefs and practices, by an Orthodox Jew, who is also a leading novelist.
Its contents cover Jewish history and survival, The faith of Judaism, Shabbat, Festivals, High Holy Days, Minor Holy Days, Prayers, Synagogue and Worship,Food Clothing and Shelter., Birth and Jewish life cycles, Love and Marriage., Explainations of the Torah and Talmud, Differences in expressions of Judaism,Israel, etc.
I obtained a copy from the local public libarary, Publishing details were as I provided with my assignment reference.
Hope this is useful for you
Toda Raba
Ari
Shalom Ari,
You're welcome. My goal is to assist you where possible.
Thank you for the prompt information... also...
G-d willing I will check into this book.
Please don't forget to check out my new book releases at: bnti.us/books.html
Blessings, Love and peace!
Dr. Akiva Gamliel